
Hiring someone to work on your siding, roof or gutters is a big decision. The work protects your home from rain, snow and wind for decades. A good job is easy to forget about. A bad one shows up as leaks, rot and repeat repairs.
★★★★★ Garden State Home Exteriors has 400+ five-star reviews from New Jersey homeowners.
Most homeowners in Bergen, Passaic, Essex and Union counties collect a few estimates before they choose. One is cheaper. One promises a faster start. One talks about a longer warranty. This guide explains how to compare them fairly, which questions to ask, and which warning signs mean you should keep looking.
Start With What You Actually Need
Before you call anyone, walk around the house and write down what you see. Note loose or cracked siding, stains on ceilings, curling shingles, overflowing gutters and soft wood at the roof edge. Take photos. This list keeps every estimate focused on the same problems.
Also decide whether you are planning one project or several. Roof, siding, windows and gutters overlap at the roof edge and around every window. If more than one is on your list, read our guide on what order to replace your roof, siding, windows and gutters before you sign anything. The order affects cost and how well the pieces seal together.
Get Three Written Estimates
Three estimates is a good number. It is enough to see a pattern without wearing you out. If two contractors describe the job the same way and the third is very different, ask the third one why.
Every estimate should be in writing. A number on the back of a business card is not an estimate. A written estimate protects you and the contractor because both sides know exactly what was promised.
What a good estimate includes
- The full scope of work, area by area
- Product names, lines and colors, not just “vinyl siding” or “shingles”
- Tear-off and disposal of old materials, including who supplies the dumpster
- How rot or damaged sheathing will be handled if it is found
- Trim, flashing, housewrap and underlayment details
- Expected start date and how long the work should take
- Material warranty and workmanship warranty, in writing
- Payment schedule
- Cleanup and what is excluded
For roofing, the estimate should reflect things that change labor: roof pitch, how easy the roof is to reach, how many layers come off, and how many valleys, chimneys and skylights need flashing. If two roof prices are far apart, these details usually explain why.
Look Beyond the Lowest Price
Price matters. But a low number can hide thin materials, rushed labor, missing flashing or a weak warranty. It can also hide “extras” that show up after the old siding or shingles come off.
Ask each contractor to explain their price. A good one can tell you why they are higher or lower than another bid. Questions worth asking:
- What exact materials are included?
- Is all labor included, including trim and flashing?
- What happens if you find rot? How is it priced?
- Is cleanup and haul-away included?
- What could change the final price?
If a price looks too good to be true and the contractor cannot explain it, treat that as a warning sign.
Expect an Inspection Before a Price
A serious estimate starts with someone looking at your home. Every house is different, and the condition under the surface drives the cost.

- Siding: the contractor should check for soft sheathing, moisture, failed flashing around windows and damaged trim.
- Roofing: they should look at shingles, flashing, decking, attic ventilation and signs of past leaks.
- Gutters: they should check fascia condition, pitch, downspout locations and where water goes after it leaves the downspout.
Be wary of anyone who quotes a full job over the phone or from a satellite photo. Without an inspection, the estimate may not match the real work, and you pay for the surprises later.
Check Registration and Insurance
In New Jersey, home improvement contractors must be registered with the Division of Consumer Affairs. The registration number belongs on the contract and on the contractor’s paperwork. Ask for it, and look it up.
Ask for proof of insurance too. Siding and roofing crews work on ladders and roofs. If someone is hurt and the company has no workers’ compensation or liability coverage, you do not want that problem landing on you. A reputable company will send certificates without any fuss.
Compare Warranties Carefully
There are two kinds of warranty on exterior work, and they cover different things.
- Material warranty: from the manufacturer. It covers product defects, like panels that crack or shingles that fail early under normal conditions.
- Workmanship warranty: from the contractor. It covers the installation itself.
Most problems on siding and roofs come from installation, not the product. Nails driven too tight, missing expansion gaps and poor flashing will not be covered by the manufacturer. That makes the workmanship warranty the one to read closely. Ask how long it lasts, what it covers, and how you file a claim. Get it in writing.
Ask About Materials, Not Just Brands
Two contractors can both say “vinyl siding” and mean very different products. Siding varies in thickness, locking design, insulation backing and color fade protection. Roofing varies in shingle line, underlayment and ventilation parts. Gutters vary in size, metal thickness and hanger spacing.
A good contractor explains why a product fits your house, not just what it costs. If you want to compare siding products yourself, our guide to siding materials for New Jersey homes covers vinyl, fiber cement, composite and PVC trim side by side.
For reference, Garden State Home Exteriors installs siding from Alside, CertainTeed and James Hardie with Azek PVC trim, roofing from Owens Corning, GAF and CertainTeed, and windows from Andersen, Pella, Marvin, Alside and OKNA. Our showrooms in Hillsdale (150 Broadway), Fairfield (24 Little Falls Rd) and Little Falls (463 Main St) have working window, siding and roofing displays, so you can see and handle the products before you choose.
Make Sure the Timeline Is Realistic
Everyone wants the job done fast. But a contractor who promises a very quick start without inspecting your home is guessing. Weather, material deliveries and hidden damage all affect the schedule in North Jersey.
A clear timeline should tell you:
- When the job can start
- How many working days it should take
- What happens on rain days
- When materials will arrive and where they will be stored
- How you will hear about delays
Ask Who Will Be Your Point of Contact
On a multi-day project, questions come up. Where does the dumpster go? Can the crew start early? What color is the trim around the back door? You should know exactly who to call or text, and that person should answer.
Ask whether the company uses its own crews or subcontractors, and who checks the work at the end of each day. At Garden State Home Exteriors, each client has a project manager who is the main point of contact from the first visit to the final walk-through.
Pay Attention to How They Communicate Now
The estimate process is a preview of the project. Notice whether the contractor:
- Shows up when they said they would
- Answers your questions directly
- Explains options without pressure
- Returns calls and emails in a reasonable time
- Puts promises in writing
A company that is hard to reach before it has your deposit will rarely get easier to reach after.
Read Reviews the Right Way
Star ratings are a start, but the details matter more. Read what homeowners say about communication, cleanup, staying on budget and how problems were handled. One bad review is not a dealbreaker. A pattern of the same complaint is.
Ask for references or addresses of recent jobs nearby. Driving past a house that was sided or roofed a few years ago tells you a lot about how the work holds up.
One of our clients, Joseph, described his project as seamless and stress-free. He said Nuno and the team, especially Josh, were professional, thorough and responsive, and fair on pricing. That kind of detail, more than the star count, is what to look for in any contractor’s reviews.
Red Flags to Watch For
- A price given without seeing the house
- Pressure to sign today for a “special” price
- No written estimate or contract
- No registration number or proof of insurance
- Vague answers about materials or flashing
- Avoiding questions about the workmanship warranty
- A large cash deposit before materials are ordered
- A door-to-door pitch right after a storm
Getting Your Home Ready
Once you choose a contractor, a little preparation makes the job smoother:
- Move cars out of the driveway so the crew and dumpster have room.
- Take down pictures and shelves on exterior walls. Hammering and tear-off can shake them loose.
- Move patio furniture, grills and planters away from the house.
- For a roof job, cover items stored in the attic. Dust and small debris can fall through.
- Keep pets and kids clear of the work area.
- Agree on where materials and the dumpster will sit.
Compare the Full Value
The cheapest bid is not always the strongest value, and the most expensive is not always the safest. The right choice is usually the company that gives you a clear written estimate, good materials, a realistic schedule, a workmanship warranty you understand, and straight answers.
Cost does not have to decide the material. Garden State Home Exteriors offers 0% interest financing for up to two years, with no payments for the first 12 months. And because roof, siding and window replacement need no permit in New Jersey, there is no permit fee or permit wait to plan around.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many estimates should I get?
Three is a practical number. It gives you enough to spot a price or scope that is out of line without dragging the process out.
What should I ask a roofing contractor before hiring?
Ask what shingle line and underlayment they will use, how they handle flashing and ventilation, what happens if they find damaged decking, and what their workmanship warranty covers. If roofing is on your list, you can read more about our roof replacement and installation process.
What is the difference between a material and a workmanship warranty?
The manufacturer’s material warranty covers product defects. The contractor’s workmanship warranty covers the installation. Since most failures come from installation, the workmanship warranty deserves the closest read.
Why does gutter work matter so much?
Gutters carry roof water away from your walls and foundation. Poorly pitched or undersized gutters overflow, soak the fascia and send water toward the basement. Good gutter installation and replacement starts with sound fascia and downspouts that discharge away from the house.
Can I see materials before choosing?
Yes. Our three showrooms have working displays, and we can create 3D renderings of your home with the siding and trim colors you are considering.
Next Step
If you are planning a siding, roofing or gutter project, compare contractors using the checklist above. When you want a second opinion, we are glad to inspect your home and give you a free written estimate. You can learn more about our siding installation and replacement work, or contact us to schedule a visit.
Find a Siding Contractor in Your Town
We install, replace and repair siding across North Jersey. Pick your county to see siding in your town:
Bergen County
- Siding in Allendale
- Siding in Alpine
- Siding in Bergenfield
- Siding in Bogota
- Siding in Carlstadt
- Siding in Cliffside Park
- Siding in Closter
- Siding in Cresskill
- Siding in Demarest
- Siding in Dumont
- Siding in East Rutherford
- Siding in Edgewater
- Siding in Elmwood Park
- Siding in Emerson
- Siding in Englewood
- Siding in Englewood Cliffs
- Siding in Fair Lawn
- Siding in Fairview
- Siding in Fort Lee
- Siding in Franklin Lakes
- Siding in Garfield
- Siding in Glen Rock
- Siding in Hackensack
- Siding in Harrington Park
- Siding in Hasbrouck Heights
- Siding in Haworth
- Siding in Hillsdale
- Siding in Ho-Ho-Kus
- Siding in Leonia
- Siding in Little Ferry
- Siding in Lodi
- Siding in Lyndhurst
- Siding in Mahwah
- Siding in Maywood
- Siding in Midland Park
- Siding in Montvale
- Siding in Moonachie
- Siding in New Milford
- Siding in Northvale
- Siding in Oakland
- Siding in Old Tappan
- Siding in Oradell
- Siding in Palisades Park
- Siding in Paramus
- Siding in Park Ridge
- Siding in Ramsey
- Siding in Ridgefield
- Siding in Ridgefield Park
- Siding in Ridgewood
- Siding in River Edge
- Siding in River Vale
- Siding in Rochelle Park
- Siding in Rutherford
- Siding in Saddle Brook
- Siding in Saddle River
- Siding in Teaneck
- Siding in Tenafly
- Siding in Township of Washington
- Siding in Upper Saddle River
- Siding in Waldwick
- Siding in Wallington
- Siding in Westwood
- Siding in Wood-Ridge
- Siding in Woodcliff Lake
- Siding in Wyckoff
Passaic County
Essex County
- Siding in Belleville
- Siding in Bloomfield
- Siding in Caldwell
- Siding in Cedar Grove
- Siding in East Orange
- Siding in Essex Fells
- Siding in Fairfield
- Siding in Glen Ridge
- Siding in Irvington
- Siding in Livingston
- Siding in Maplewood
- Siding in Millburn
- Siding in Montclair
- Siding in Newark
- Siding in Nutley
- Siding in Orange
- Siding in Roseland
- Siding in Short Hills
- Siding in South Orange
- Siding in Verona
- Siding in West Orange
Morris County
Morris County
Union County
Find a Roofing Contractor in Your Town
We install, replace and repair roofs across North Jersey. Pick your county to see roofing in your town:
Bergen County
- Roofing in Allendale
- Roofing in Alpine
- Roofing in Bergenfield
- Roofing in Bogota
- Roofing in Carlstadt
- Roofing in Cliffside Park
- Roofing in Closter
- Roofing in Cresskill
- Roofing in Demarest
- Roofing in Dumont
- Roofing in East Rutherford
- Roofing in Edgewater
- Roofing in Elmwood Park
- Roofing in Emerson
- Roofing in Englewood
- Roofing in Englewood Cliffs
- Roofing in Fair Lawn
- Roofing in Fairview
- Roofing in Fort Lee
- Roofing in Franklin Lakes
- Roofing in Garfield
- Roofing in Glen Rock
- Roofing in Hackensack
- Roofing in Harrington Park
- Roofing in Hasbrouck Heights
- Roofing in Haworth
- Roofing in Hillsdale
- Roofing in Ho-Ho-Kus
- Roofing in Leonia
- Roofing in Little Ferry
- Roofing in Lodi
- Roofing in Lyndhurst
- Roofing in Mahwah
- Roofing in Maywood
- Roofing in Midland Park
- Roofing in Montvale
- Roofing in Moonachie
- Roofing in New Milford
- Roofing in Northvale
- Roofing in Oakland
- Roofing in Old Tappan
- Roofing in Oradell
- Roofing in Palisades Park
- Roofing in Paramus
- Roofing in Park Ridge
- Roofing in Ramsey
- Roofing in Ridgefield
- Roofing in Ridgefield Park
- Roofing in Ridgewood
- Roofing in River Edge
- Roofing in River Vale
- Roofing in Rochelle Park
- Roofing in Rutherford
- Roofing in Saddle Brook
- Roofing in Saddle River
- Roofing in Teaneck
- Roofing in Tenafly
- Roofing in Township of Washington
- Roofing in Upper Saddle River
- Roofing in Waldwick
- Roofing in Wallington
- Roofing in Westwood
- Roofing in Wood-Ridge
- Roofing in Woodcliff Lake
- Roofing in Wyckoff
Passaic County
- Roofing in Bloomingdale
- Roofing in Clifton
- Roofing in Haledon
- Roofing in Hawthorne
- Roofing in Little Falls
- Roofing in North Haledon
- Roofing in Passaic
- Roofing in Pompton Lakes
- Roofing in Prospect Park
- Roofing in Ringwood
- Roofing in Totowa
- Roofing in Wanaque
- Roofing in Wayne
- Roofing in West Milford
- Roofing in Woodland Park
Essex County
- Roofing in Belleville
- Roofing in Bloomfield
- Roofing in Caldwell
- Roofing in Cedar Grove
- Roofing in East Orange
- Roofing in Essex Fells
- Roofing in Fairfield
- Roofing in Glen Ridge
- Roofing in Irvington
- Roofing in Livingston
- Roofing in Maplewood
- Roofing in Millburn
- Roofing in Montclair
- Roofing in Newark
- Roofing in Nutley
- Roofing in Orange
- Roofing in Roseland
- Roofing in Short Hills
- Roofing in South Orange
- Roofing in Verona
- Roofing in West Orange
Morris County
Union County
Somerset County
Find Gutter Installation in Your Town
We install, replace and repair seamless gutters across North Jersey. Pick your county to see gutters in your town:
Bergen County
Gutter Installation in Bergen County
- Gutter Installation in Allendale
- Gutter Installation in Alpine
- Gutter Installation in Bergenfield
- Gutter Installation in Bogota
- Gutter Installation in Carlstadt
- Gutter Installation in Cliffside Park
- Gutter Installation in Closter
- Gutter Installation in Cresskill
- Gutter Installation in Demarest
- Gutter Installation in Dumont
- Gutter Installation in East Rutherford
- Gutter Installation in Edgewater
- Gutter Installation in Elmwood Park
- Gutter Installation in Emerson
- Gutter Installation in Englewood
- Gutter Installation in Englewood Cliffs
- Gutter Installation in Fair Lawn
- Gutter Installation in Fairview
- Gutter Installation in Fort Lee
- Gutter Installation in Franklin Lakes
- Gutter Installation in Garfield
- Gutter Installation in Glen Rock
- Gutter Installation in Hackensack
- Gutter Installation in Harrington Park
- Gutter Installation in Hasbrouck Heights
- Gutter Installation in Haworth
- Gutter Installation in Hillsdale
- Gutter Installation in Ho-Ho-Kus
- Gutter Installation in Leonia
- Gutter Installation in Little Ferry
- Gutter Installation in Lodi
- Gutter Installation in Lyndhurst
- Gutter Installation in Mahwah
- Gutter Installation in Maywood
- Gutter Installation in Midland Park
- Gutter Installation in Montvale
- Gutter Installation in Moonachie
- Gutter Installation in New Milford
- Gutter Installation in Northvale
- Gutter Installation in Oakland
- Gutter Installation in Old Tappan
- Gutter Installation in Oradell
- Gutter Installation in Palisades Park
- Gutter Installation in Paramus
- Gutter Installation in Park Ridge
- Gutter Installation in Ramsey
- Gutter Installation in Ridgefield
- Gutter Installation in Ridgefield Park
- Gutter Installation in Ridgewood
- Gutter Installation in River Edge
- Gutter Installation in River Vale
- Gutter Installation in Rochelle Park
- Gutter Installation in Rutherford
- Gutter Installation in Saddle Brook
- Gutter Installation in Saddle River
- Gutter Installation in Teaneck
- Gutter Installation in Tenafly
- Gutter Installation in Township of Washington
- Gutter Installation in Upper Saddle River
- Gutter Installation in Waldwick
- Gutter Installation in Wallington
- Gutter Installation in Westwood
- Gutter Installation in Wood-Ridge
- Gutter Installation in Woodcliff Lake
- Gutter Installation in Wyckoff
Passaic County
Gutter Installation in Passaic County
- Gutter Installation in Bloomingdale
- Gutter Installation in Clifton
- Gutter Installation in Haledon
- Gutter Installation in Hawthorne
- Gutter Installation in Little Falls
- Gutter Installation in North Haledon
- Gutter Installation in Passaic
- Gutter Installation in Pompton Lakes
- Gutter Installation in Prospect Park
- Gutter Installation in Ringwood
- Gutter Installation in Totowa
- Gutter Installation in Wanaque
- Gutter Installation in Wayne
- Gutter Installation in West Milford
- Gutter Installation in Woodland Park
Essex County
Gutter Installation in Essex County
- Gutter Installation in Belleville
- Gutter Installation in Bloomfield
- Gutter Installation in Caldwell
- Gutter Installation in Cedar Grove
- Gutter Installation in East Orange
- Gutter Installation in Essex Fells
- Gutter Installation in Fairfield
- Gutter Installation in Glen Ridge
- Gutter Installation in Irvington
- Gutter Installation in Livingston
- Gutter Installation in Maplewood
- Gutter Installation in Millburn
- Gutter Installation in Montclair
- Gutter Installation in Newark
- Gutter Installation in Nutley
- Gutter Installation in Orange
- Gutter Installation in Roseland
- Gutter Installation in Short Hills
- Gutter Installation in South Orange
- Gutter Installation in Verona
- Gutter Installation in West Orange
Morris County
- Gutter Installation in Boonton
- Gutter Installation in Butler
- Gutter Installation in Cedar Knolls
- Gutter Installation in Chatham
- Gutter Installation in Denville
- Gutter Installation in Dover
- Gutter Installation in East Hanover
- Gutter Installation in Florham Park
- Gutter Installation in Hanover
- Gutter Installation in Kinnelon
- Gutter Installation in Lincoln Park
- Gutter Installation in Montville
- Gutter Installation in Pequannock
- Gutter Installation in Riverdale